Just got off the Muse, our second SS cruise. Will never go on SS again. While the service was excellent as was the ship the food was the worst we have ever experienced on any cruise ship. The menus sound wonderful but they are all bark and no bite. Ingredients are left out, food was usually cold except when we cooked it ourselves. We ordered Pizza Margherita and there was no basil. Instead they used arugula and tried to palm it off as basil. All they needed to have done was to say we are out of basil and we would have ordered something else. The ingredients seldom seemed fresh, particular the fruit, and many of the dishes were very bland to our taste.
As others have said I think the SS executives should try travelling on other luxury lines to discover what luxury cruising is really. It may have just been a one off bad experience on the Muse but there were so many things not right that we would not want to take a risk again especially when we know there are alternatives like SB and Oceania and Viking.