When I was on the pearl last year, the whiskey bar had a Woodford Old Fashioned (cocktail) that was included in the regular package, but if you wanted just straight Woodford (neat or rocks) it was above the $15 limit, and therefore had the upcharge. It didn't make much sense to me, as the quantity of bourbon felt the same (but it could have been a significant amount more when ordering straight, who knows). I enjoy an Old Fashioned, so I didn't mind. But if your husband only wants it straight, perhaps you could try to sweet talk the bar tender into making you the Woodford Old Fashioned without the extra stuff. 😉