I just returned from Cozumel, we had the debate as well- we actually went to Playa Mia for a few reasons -1- it was cheaper and had all the same things as Mr. Sanchos and Paradise(food, water toys, beach, snorkeling, open bar) 2- it was highly recommend by friends who cruise often and they go every time 3- had big water slide for grown ups!4- felt very safe with kids. If you go ask for Mario he is the best your drinks will never run out!! Its basically next door to Paradise beach! Anything you decided I’m sure you’ll have fun! They are all great!