Seacow vs Royal Caribbean snorkel & beach break

[rpanda]

We'll be on a Royal Caribbean cruise soon, and I can't decide between the Seacow double dip snorkel (booked through the ship) or the Bonaire Marine Park snorkel & Klein Bonaire beach break. The latter is less expensive but there aren't really any details about shade on the boat, and I'm not sure which snorkel location is better, or if they're all good anyway. I've snorkeled a few times, my mom has not. Has anyone been on either or both? Which would you recommend? 

[trophy_23]

Heard from a family member that Seacow is excellent. We went with woodwind and it was great! The boat was nice and comfortable, refreshments and food provided was great.  Good equipment too  for people (we had our own).  Small groups went with each guide, divided up by skill level.  Would use them again.

[rpanda]

I looked into Woodwind but they aren't going out that day, sadly. Thank you for your suggestion!