Which would you choose?

On our April 18 RCCL Independence of the Seas cruise we will be stopping in Jamaica on Thursday April 21st. We are trying to decide which Resort For A Day tour to take, either Hilton Rose Hill or Jewel Paradise Cove (adult only). Both are all inclusive and basically around the same cost. We are 3 adult women, ages between 58 and 91. Which would you choose?

Forgot to add that we are ported in Falmouth. Transfers are included in both by the transfer to Jewel Paradise Cove is about 15 minutes further than Hilton Rose Hill.