Which snorkel option

We are looking at either Turtle Bay Sail & Snorkel or Buck Island Sail & Snorkel. Both are through the ship (we prefer that). Turtle Bay is $10 more and is on a pirate schooner and Buck Island is on a catamaran. Just wonder if one is a better option over the other. Thanks.

We are going on the Buck Island in two weeks. I'll post back after the trip.

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app

Anyone else got experience with these 2 excursions?

Both went to the same place on our cruise. I think that is normal. From our experience the catamaran took longer to get to the island vs. the schooner. Saw a couple turtles and would have preferred to stay at that location over going to the second shipwreck. I would say about a 50 minutes total time in the water. If I could do all over again we would do a private tour. (We normally do this but had OBC to use).

Sent from my iPhone using Forums mobile app