Sunny Liston vs. Godfrey Tours?

Just curious if someone has done both Sunny Liston and Godfrey Tours and can comment about the pros and cons of both tours.

In St Thomas, we booked Sunny Liston Tours...We're doing the tour and beach package and they give you refreshments. I looked them up on TripAdvisors and there were some awesome reviews. I went directly to their website and booked.

I ended up using Godfrey. I tried to set up a private tour group with Sunny Liston and due to a miscommunication it was cancelled by them & no one wanted to book with them again after that.

We did enjoy a great tour with Godfrey!

Oh wow...Ok, thanks...Hopefully everything goes well with us, I haven't had anything happen yet. I went by the reviews, that's why I booked them.

I used them before and had a great time. The miscommunication was the fault of both of us but when he emailed the cancellation to everyone before telling the group leader (me!) it was hard to get people to sign up again.

I hope you have as much fun as I did in St. Thomas.

We were wanting to book with Godfrey Tours, but it didn't seem that you could reserve the exact tour and date with the deposit payment. I sent an email on Sunday asking some questions and never heard back. We're probably gonna just wing it when we get to St Thomas.

I used godfrey tours without any issues. Enjoy the island :D

Thanks so much AuntieBon!!!

Sunny Liston looks a little more live and fun to me, from the website and reviews, that's why I chose them...But I will see and come back with my own review lol