We've posted our Wind Surf Review - Nice to Lisbon

We've just posted a full review of our B-to-B Wind Surf cruises, Nice to Barcelona (11/7-14/2004) and Barcelona to Lisbon (11/14-21/2004). It's mostly favorable, but we don't hide the (few) warts.

It will take a few days for the review to appear. We, or a watchful reader of this thread, will let you know when the review becomes available.:cool:

Where can I find your review? Thanks

The review has been posted, probably after Mousemeat asked. On the home page, go to reviews on the far left of the page, click on Windstar, and that will get you to the professional reviews. Click on member reviews and the two member reviews, including ours, will become available. The direct link is http://www.cruisecritic.com/memberreviews/memberreview.cfm?EntryID=7746

but we're not sure if it works.

Thanks, Joanand joe, and the link DOES work. It sounds like you had a good time in spite of a few things.

Thanks for the review. One can't hold a cruise line responsible for 60 knot winds and seasickness. However, there were a few issues that may well have been handled better. While our group awaited your return and review, we met and decided on the "safer" trip of Venice to Athens on the Diamond for August 2005.

When we plan our next cruise by ourselves, I would be interested in the WindStar, especially if Lisbon, Spain, Morocco, are in the itinerary.

Thanks again

Zamost, thanks for the heads up. As I mentioned before, either Radisson or Windstar would have been a good choice. I'm not sure that the Diamond is a "safer" choice than Windstar, since it's chartered so frequently. See the posting on the Radisson board about "RSSC-never again!"

Yes, Windstar could have handled the bathroom problem better on our unanticipated wind and sea day; but conditions were so bad that they were overwhelmed. The good parts of the cruise were much more significant than the bad parts, and we had a great time.