Cruise to Canada or Baltics

I'm considering my next cruise and am between an 11-13 day Canada cruise from NY to Canada or a 9ish day Baltic cruise. I live on the west coast, so will be traveling regardless; however, my family is on the east coast and would be able to get taxi to NY port, but they are totally up for a European adventure.

Travelers would be myself (f32) and my dad (m73) and possibly my brother (m34) and sister (f28). Most of us have travelled extensively, so we appreciate the lesser known ports. I'm looking for insight into what is a better cruise. Thanks!

Obviously two totally different areas. Baltics are great and much history. I'd say go for that. Note airfare will be a killer though.

I would agree with the Baltics... only because I grew up in New England and don't really consider New England and Canada to be exotic when I can drive there...