Silver Whisper ratings low?

[bearhall]

I have been reading the review ratings on Cruise Critic, some are not too flattering. Does anyone know why the Whisper is not rated as good as the rest of the fleet?

[Signor John]

I'd imagine the statistical sample is too small to have much meaning, but that's just a guess.

[JPR]

Bingo. One reviewer failed to give stars but clearly would have given five stars, as did others, based on the substance of their review. The three star reviewer's review seems better than the rating given.

 

The only bad review of the five (one star, which brought down the overall score) was from the appropriately named "Amazing." Read the incredibly picky review and then consider the source. Res ipsa loquitur, as we lawyers say...

[DebbieH103]

The Whisper experience is magnificent. I would not worry. I think my review is there from last year. If not, email me at debbieh103@aol.com, and I will send that and my Wind review from March. We are going back on Whisper on 12/1 and cannot wait.

[Prince]

Thank you for that re-assurance! I have two cruises on the Whisper and I am looking forward to them.

 

Prince