Great stirrup vs. Princess cay

[cruizinonup]

I have read that Half Moon Cay is far superior to Great stirrup and Princess, but how do princess and GSC compare?

[neptune18]

We loved Princess cays. GSC is a beautiful beach with clear water but NCL has a lot of nerve putting that many people in such a small area (we were on the Pearl). By 11:00 it was unbearably crowded with people literally plopping their chairs inches in front of us. Also, lunch was not good- ice cold burgers.

[Mikenbabbs]

We enjoyed Princess Cays. The BBQ was good (and free) and the beach was quiet and enjoyable.

[shark_bait]

Not even close IMHO. Princess hands down much nicer, though not as nice as Half Moon. As Neptune said, GSC is not set up to handle the amount of passengers that these new mega liners bring in. It looked to me that it was put together in 70's and very little done to it since then.