Personal experience on these excursions?

Please help me with this decision. We (my two daughters and I) will be stopping at Grand Cayman in October. For safety reason, my husband would prefer we only use Carnival excursions. We have done the stingrays before, and we want to go again...But which of the stingray excursions offered by Carnival is the best. I've read good and bad review for all. I can't decide. Please help:

Stingray Sandbar & Star Fish Point

Stingray Encounter & Turtle Swim

Allura Catamaran Sail to Stingray City Sandba

Stingray City Sandbar & Tiki Beach Combo

Deluxe Stingray City Sandbar for All Ages

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

it's too bad you are limited to the cruise line options. You may want to read reviews on these excursions on the CCL site as well.

Don't know since we cannot see what each of these entails, but personally, I LOVE to take a catamaran sail. Much nicer than a motorboat to be gliding along the clear blue waters of that bay. I have never had a bad day on a catamaran excursion on any island. Just lovely.

I am also interested in hearing reviews from people who have been on the Carnival stingray/snorkelling catamaran tour recently. The reviews on the carnival site are old. Thanks!

We're doing the Sea Safari, which is kayaking through the mangroves, then into the stingrays.

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

You and your husband might be interested in this thread and then maybe book an excursion on your own. The cruise line's are overpriced and crowded

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=2444428

I am also interested in hearing reviews from people who have been on the Carnival stingray/snorkelling catamaran tour recently. The reviews on the carnival site are old. Thanks!

Most reviews here are with independent operators but you may see some feedback.

Are you looking at the excursion page on the CCA site and the reviews specific to that excursion? I know they are not always current but worth checking. Also under the "Reviews" tab on the main cc page for cruises with the same port.