car rental for the day - Tony's or Nathan?

We decided we'd like a jeep or car for the day in GT just for freedom of a little exploring. I have contacted both Nathan's and Tony and both have one available, I just need to call w/CC to book. Is one "better" than the other? Or does anyone know if there would be availability to just show up and rent while there? Thanks for sharing any past experiences! ---kp

We decided we'd like a jeep or car for the day in GT just for freedom of a little exploring. I have contacted both Nathan's and Tony and both have one available, I just need to call w/CC to book. Is one "better" than the other? Or does anyone know if there would be availability to just show up and rent while there? Thanks for sharing any past experiences! ---kp

I'd like to know this too! We're wanting a Jeep ...

We went with Nathan for golf cart rental and had to pay in advance. Had no problems. You definitely need to make a reservation and book ahead of time as there is a very limited supply of Jeeps also.

Has anyone recently used Tony's for a Car or Jeep rental? If so, how was your experience? Where did you have to go to pick up vehicle?