Good morning all. Got home yesterday from a 7 day Caribbean cruise on Breakaway, my first time on BA, second on NCL. Our cruise had 3,000 passengers. I was very apprehensive because of the many negative reviews I've read, but overall it was better than I expected.
The good:
The ship was beautiful and in great shape. It looked brand new.
Food in the MDR was good, but not great.
Six and Burn the Floor were fantastic.
No masks required for passengers! We were constantly being told that masks were required in ports and on excursions, but that was not the case at all.
The "meh":
Service was just okay. I experienced a lot of fake smiles and indifferent attitudes. Not nearly as friendly as my recent cruise on the Gem.
I was concerned about that infamous smoke stench in the atrium. It wasn't really an issue. Just a slight stale cigarette smell.
The bad:
I was shocked there was no poolside grill! This forced everyone into the over-crowded buffet.
Large areas of the buffet were constantly roped off making it a crowded zoo most of the time.
Just like on the Gem, O'Sheehans was a joke with the constant din from the overcrowded atrium. The open floor plan doesn't really work.
Disembarkation was chaotic with only one staffer managing hundreds of people in line.