Thoughts on the Fantasy out of Mobile New Years Eve

Like the title says.

We have done the Sunshine a few times, plus the Freedom, Fascination and Dream. I know the Fantasy is one of the oldest ships, but went through a Fun 2.0 in 2016. Looking to get input on the following;

1. Freedom as an updated ship. We don't go to shows or the Casino. More about relaxing, food and some (many) adult beverages.

2. New Years Eve cruise. We did a Christmas cruise in 2017 which was fun. Kids (3) - 13/11/8 thoroughly enjoyed it. For us, there was little that was different over a regular cruise.

3. Port of Mobile. We have traveled out of JAX, Canaveral and Miami. Canaveral is by far the easiest port we have used and in always quick to embark/disembark.

4. Western Caribbean vs Eastern. Most of our cruises have been Eastern or Bahamas. Thoughts on weather differences and what we can possibly expect at that time of year.

I know that each of these has been individually covered elsewhere, but so have all questions that come up here. Looking more for current experiences of how people have enjoyed that specific route in general, noting our preferences.

Many thanks in advance.