St. Lucia or Aruba?

[Bold Spirit]

We have to choose between a cruise that includes St. Lucia or one that includes Aruba. Which would you prefer and why.:confused:

[chrysalis]

St Lucia...because we love to go whale-watching with Hackshaw's for the day.

[Bold Spirit]

Thanks! Any others?:) Need opinions!

[Charisse4]

ARUBA!

Although St. Lucia is absolutely beautiful, I prefer Aruba because I am totally comfortable going across the street, getting the local bus and taking it to the beach. I don't like going to countries that I'm afraid to walk around on my own. So......guess I like it cuz it's comfortable!;)

[Bold Spirit]

Thanks for your opinions!

[Aligator6182]

Aruba! We have been there twice and loved it both times. Once we just went to Palm Beach for a relaxing day. The second time we went to DePalm island for snorkeling. The downtown area is really good for shopping and there are quite a few good bars and restaurants too. We stopped in St. Lucia once, did a day pass at the sandals. Although the sandals was nice, we were not real comfortable in the shopping area.

[Bold Spirit]

I think we'll opt for Aruba; maybe we can do St. Lucia someday!