Which Ports for diving on Western Itinerary????

[StingRaysfan]

We just back from an Eastern Caribbean cruise during which we did dives in Grand Turk and St. Thomas. I had read there would be a difference between the two sites, but I wasn't prepared for how much the diving in Grand Turk totally blew away St. Thomas...

 

So, now we are looking at booking a Western cruise in December on the Carnival Liberty... which is going to Cozumel, Belize, Roatan, and Grand Cayman. We probably only want to dive two of these ports. I think my research has already eliminated Belize.... but the other 3 are killing me!!!! Nothing I've read has been a definitive "we should dive this port over the other." So for anyone that's done these three... which two should we do????

 

Thanks!!!

[Laurie S.]

I would go with Cozumel and Roatan.

[Kryssa]

Do you like drift diving?

 

If yes, Roatan and Coz.

 

If no, Roatan and Grand Cayman.

 

If you like "touristy" dives, check out Sting Ray City diver in Grand Cayman.