Honeymoon Beach v. Magens Bay

[Crazy planning mom]

I have a cruise scheduled that stops in St. Thomas.  A colleague and friend recently spent a few days in St. Thomas.  She wasn't overly impressed with St. Thomas and recommended St. John which she loved visiting for the day.  There is a champagne catamaran excursion that goes to St. John.  We aren't snorkelers and would enjoy the catamaran and beach.  On the other hand, I have read/heard others sing the praises of Megan's Bay.  Which would you do?

[blue_water]

9 hours ago, Crazy planning mom said:

I have a cruise scheduled that stops in St. Thomas.  A colleague and friend recently spent a few days in St. Thomas.  She wasn't overly impressed with St. Thomas and recommended St. John which she loved visiting for the day.  There is a champagne catamaran excursion that goes to St. John.  We aren't snorkelers and would enjoy the catamaran and beach.  On the other hand, I have read/heard others sing the praises of Megan's Bay.  Which would you do?

The Champagne cat, hands down…

[blue_water]

On 6/20/2022 at 7:38 PM, blue_water said:

The Champagne cat, hands down…

Having said that, many visitors just head to the most-touted beaches (i.e. Magens Bay) and then go to STJ and never see the beauty and history STT has to offer… 
But friends always rave about the champagne cat excursion…