Which would you pick?

[tgr2387]

I keep flipping back and forth between:

 

Carnival Valor(3/15/09): Belize, Grand Cayman, Roatan, Cozumel

Carnival Triumph(3/15/09): San Juan, St Martin, St Thomas

 

I'm not too worried about price, and I've been to nearly all of these places. I don't mind going on the same itinerary I just recently went on either. However, I haven't been on either of these ships. From what I've read the Valor seems to be the winner. I just can't decide between these two cruises. Which would you pick?

 

On a side note my signature says Valor, but recently I have been contimplating the Triumph cruise.

[Payd]

I keep flipping back and forth between:

 

Carnival Valor(3/15/09): Belize, Grand Cayman, Roatan, Cozumel

Carnival Triumph(3/15/09): San Juan, St Martin, St Thomas

 

I'm not too worried about price, and I've been to nearly all of these places. I don't mind going on the same itinerary I just recently went on either. However, I haven't been on either of these ships. From what I've read the Valor seems to be the winner. I just can't decide between these two cruises. Which would you pick?

 

On a side note my signature says Valor, but recently I have been contimplating the Triumph cruise.

 

All of these ports are fabulous as you already know. If I wanted more relaxation time, sea days I'd go Triumph. For fabulous ports, relaxation I'd go with Valor.

 

The Triumph probably rates at the bottom of our cruises (never a bad cruise though!!), and I haven't been on Valor.

 

Valor wins:).

[drumline]

Valor was great, going again this March. Was on the Victory, which is a sister ship to the Triumph, was nice but would definately liked the Valor better. Have fun.

[kelz66]

I keep flipping back and forth between:

 

Carnival Valor(3/15/09): Belize, Grand Cayman, Roatan, Cozumel

Carnival Triumph(3/15/09): San Juan, St Martin, St Thomas

 

I'm not too worried about price, and I've been to nearly all of these places. I don't mind going on the same itinerary I just recently went on either. However, I haven't been on either of these ships. From what I've read the Valor seems to be the winner. I just can't decide between these two cruises. Which would you pick?

 

On a side note my signature says Valor, but recently I have been contemplating the Triumph cruise.

 

The Valor...because of the itin.

:cool:

[VolzCruiser]

I know this doesn't help you at all but I have to say all these ports are wonderful. To me the decision would come down to how much down time I wanted.

[KroozFoolz]

Valor ~ because John Heald is scheduled to be the CD on that sailing.

[momofzeke]

If the number of sea days vs. port days is not important to you, then I would pick Valor. I haven't been on Triumph, but I have been on Valor and loved it. Valor is 5 years newer than Triumph if that makes any difference to you.

[halos]

The Valor...because of the itin.

:cool:

 

that would be my vote as well.

[tgr2387]

Thanks everyone, I appreciate your input. I'll probably stick with my initial instinct of the Valor.