Deciding between 2 Carnival excursions in St. Thomas - Need help!

I am only planning to book one excursion through Carnival, on our 1st cruise on the Breeze in Nov. to St. Thomas.

My kids want to sea sea turtle sand sail on a catamaran, as do I!

I am having a really hard time trying to decide between these 2...

Turtle Cove Sail & Snorkel https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

Two Island Snorkel & Beach Safari by FastCat

https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

Has anyone done them before? If so did you like it?

They seem very similar except one goes to a beach after the snorkeling.

I would also be interested to hear opinions on the Two Island Snorkel & Beach Safari by FastCat.

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

I am only planning to book one excursion through Carnival, on our 1st cruise on the Breeze in Nov. to St. Thomas.

My kids want to sea sea turtle sand sail on a catamaran, as do I!

 

I am having a really hard time trying to decide between these 2...

Turtle Cove Sail & Snorkel https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

Two Island Snorkel & Beach Safari by FastCat

https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

 

Has anyone done them before? If so did you like it?

 

They seem very similar except one goes to a beach after the snorkeling.

We're trying to decide between those too also.

We decided to go with the Turtle Cove one as it is an open catamaran and we'd like to sit on it instead of being underneath in the shade ;)

I researched the Two Island excursion and found out the Honeymoon beach they visit is not in St. John, it is Honeymoon Beach at Water Island. From what I read, the snorkeling is not good there, so we will probably try a different excursion also.

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

I am only planning to book one excursion through Carnival, on our 1st cruise on the Breeze in Nov. to St. Thomas.

My kids want to sea sea turtle sand sail on a catamaran, as do I!

 

I am having a really hard time trying to decide between these 2...

Turtle Cove Sail & Snorkel https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

Two Island Snorkel & Beach Safari by FastCat

https://secure.carnival.com/Activiti...4F705130773D3D

 

Has anyone done them before? If so did you like it?

 

They seem very similar except one goes to a beach after the snorkeling.

The Two Island snorkel and Beach Safari by FastCat got great reviews on Carnival. I don't usually book excursions through Carnival, but I'm really looking forward to this one. I'll be going in October and will report back.

The Two Island snorkel and Beach Safari by FastCat got great reviews on Carnival. I don't usually book excursions through Carnival, but I'm really looking forward to this one. I'll be going in October and will report back.

Thanks! Yea I saw they both had almost the same amount of good reviews! We don't cruise til Nov. so I'm eager to hear your report!

If you want the best chance of seeing sea turtles, then go to Turtle Cove. If you just want a beach with amenities, do two beach tour.