I was on the Carnival Pride last month out of Tampa for 8 nights. I have been on HAL, Princess, RC, Celebrity and Carnival in the past. Most recently on Princess I heard multiple people criticizing Carnival and they definitely thought that a Carnival cruise was beneath them. It was fun to let them know we like Carnival and see how they respond.
I think each of the lines does different things well. Carnival is great with activities and entertainment and I found that to be true on the Pride. The cruise director and his team were great. I think HAL overall has better food than Carnival but lacks in activities. I remember one night in the main show room on HAL was pretty bad and people in my party walked out. Other entertainment on HAL is superior to Carnival.
The staff was very good on the Pride and no complaints there. The balcony cabin we had on the Pride was a good size and in good shape. The cabin was larger than my balcony cabin on a recent Princess cruise. The cabin TV was really small and the channel choices are a joke, there are a lot of Carnival channels and almost no real channels to watch. I don't watch a lot of TV on a cruise but I do like to watch some and could not find much worth watching.
Good Food on Pride - I found the dining room to be good and was happy with dinner and ate there 7 of my 8 dinners. I ate breakfast in the dining room twice and it is better than the breakfast buffet. The pizza at the Pizza Pirate station was great. PP was the only food available after 11 PM aside from paid room service. Lunch and dinner "buffet" station was overall very good and there is carved meat at lunch and dinner and at some meals the most delicious mashed potatoes. Blue Iguana is great. I loved the meat tacos and also went there for breakfast a few times. They have arepas at breakfast and they were delicious, especially with beans.
Not so good Food on Pride - The dessert station on the Lido was not to my taste and there was almost no dessert I liked or finished. The Chopstix station was not good. There is soup at Chopstix that was fine but the rest of the food was not good.
We had a couple of odd incidents on the trip. We did stop to make contact with people in a small boat to see if they needed assistance. The people on the boat did not want to get on the ship and in the end the ship provided food, blankets, water and a radio. Another day we had a "person overboard" incident. After the ship went back and there was a good amount of looking no one was found. Everyone on board had to report to their muster stations and check in. It took a while and there were people called by name that had not checked in but in the end all passengers, crew and contractors were accounted for, so it was a false alarm. Both incidents were handled very professionally by the crew.
I hope this helps and have a great trip.
Jen