Alright- Here is our experience with the Premium Plus bottles of wine...
Short version - They changed things and it sucks.
Long version - On previous sailings there has been a menu which showed the included bottles you could get from the P+ package. This is now no more. Here is what they have at all the restaurants now.
There is no longer any clarity on what's included (spelled out as included). When we asked a few different servers, it is clear there is a lot of confusion on what the right answer is. I wasn't able to get in touch with the F&B Manager, but a few different Maitre-d's we discussed this with had similar answers.
On the 'Wine by the Glass' side of the menu, anything over $15 a glass, you can get the bottle for 40% off. If it is listed under $15 a glass, the bottle is free. In general, this makes some sense, but...
When we were in Ocean Blue for dinner the first night, I saw on the OB menu (below) that bottles of Pommery Brut Rose and Veuve Clicquot are included in the Premium Plus package. These are $25 and $29 a glass respectively.
At Ocean Blue we enjoyed the Pommery Brut Rose with dinner at no charge. When we went to Le Bistro a few days later, we had no other wine menu from there that indicated the Veuve Clicquot was included in the P+ package, but we ordered it anyway and weren't charged for it - So it must be included on some secret menu outside of Ocean Blue.
Based on discussion with several Maitre-d's, these bottles should be charged for outside the OB restaurant. So...Confusion Abound.
The thing that burns my butt more are the huge price increases of some of their premium bottle offerings. On our last cruise in July '22, we enjoyed an Opus One at Cagney's - Back then it was $375 a bottle, which we received 40% off...Now, they are asking for $999 a bottle!!! 🤯
I hope this helps clarify a few things. Honestly, at this point we might start bringing on some of our better wine preferences for future cruises. 😁