Independence of the Seas or Celebrity Eclipse

[motif]

Hi,

 

We've been on Indy before and are going again this summer. Looking ahead to summer holidays in 2014, we're lucky enough to be able to go on another cruise. I've already asked the question in another post about which ships sail from Southampton. Following on from that, would you recommend Indy (again) or Celebrity Eclipse (or something else)?

 

More 'useful' info:

We are a family of 4, kids will be 14 & 12. We're not particularly loud or boisterous, and tend to keep away from organised "fun". That said, we don't want to spend our 2 weeks in an old people's home (no offence intended!). We prefer to hang out in a family unit on holidays, rather than farming the kids off to kids' clubs and the like. Also, we'll have done (western) med twice, so we could be looking at a different itinerary.

 

Many thanks :)

[Keith1010]

It's often nice to try other cruise lines and ships so I would give Celebrity a try.

 

Keith

[Krazy Kruizers]

I agree -- try Celebrity for a change.