Comparison of the Cays

[PortMaster]

Little Stirrup Cay, if anyone has been to both, how does it compare to Half Moon Cay? The same? Nicer? Not as nice?

 

We are looking at a cruise that has Little Stirrup Cay on the itinerary but have not been there before. We have been to Half Moon Cay before and loved the beach there.

 

THANKS

[hannibal54]

Little Stirrup Cay LSC, is better known as Coco Cay. I have been to both private islands. In my opinion Half Moon Cay HMC is the better of the 2 islands. The beach, the water and the set up at HMC is better. I really like Coco Cay also, I have been there more times than HMC.

[CruisinCrow]

Little Stirrup Cay (also called Coco Cay) is really nice. We've been to Coco Cay several times recently but haven't been to Half Moon Cay in many, many years.

 

If you post your question on the Private Islands board, you'll probably find more people who have been to both and can compare.

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/forumdisplay.php?f=406