Joy or Escape

[BarnCat1]

Both ships have the exact same itinerary and it’s the same time of year.
 

Escape leaves from Port Canaveral, Joy from Miami. Price difference is only $100 with the Joy being higher. It’s 5 adults going. 

Joy is newer so I’m leaning towards that right now but I would like input from those who have sailed on both ships
 

What ship would be the better choice? 

[McFins]

Love the Escape but I’m hesitant to sail on the Joy because it doesn't have the Thermal Suite.   

[RedwingHockeyFan]

I was looking at a similar situation in JAN 2021 and I chose the Joy since I have already been on the Escape.  The Bliss also had the same itinerary but was $100 more per person than the Joy.  The Escape and Joy were comparable.