BeeMinor and WTH,
We were on the same sailing. This was our first time in the Retreat and had a fantastic experience. I agree with you about Eden and Rooftop. We had fantastic dinners there. We were less impressed with Le Grand Bistro. We also both enjoyed Ralph Harris and went to his adult show as well.
Liz in the Retreat was super helpful to us. We may have just been in there at separate times.
I agree that the Retreat pool was very busy and I was often frustrated by the chair hogs. Especially those that put stuff on the Gazebo chairs and left it there for HOURS without ever going back to it.
Not sure if we ran into either one of you. We were the newlyweds with the funny t-shirts