Majesty of the Seas

I've never sailed Royal at all, and I'm trying to decide between these two ships. Seems like mostly everyone prefers Enchantment to Majesty, even though Majesty is being redone. Is this true?

Enchantment is 5 years newer than Majesty. Enchantment is actually bigger than Majesty (83K Tons vs. 74K Tons) but it has fewer cabins than Majesty (1144 vs. 1193) so that gives Enchantment a significantly better Passenger Space Ratio (30 vs. 26). Enchantment also has a solarium and a steakhouse (Chops), neither of which are in Majesty and (IMHO) the main dining room in Enchantment is more attractive than it is on Majesty although the food itself is about the same. Finally, if you are in a suite on Enchantment, there is a Concierge Club and, while it would not make any difference to a first time cruiser, Enchantment also has a Diamond Club. Majesty has neither of those although it does cordon off part of its Viking Crown Lounge every evening to provide a happy hour event for Diamonds and Suite cruisers.

Enchantment is 5 years newer than Majesty. Enchantment is actually bigger than Majesty (83K Tons vs. 74K Tons) but it has fewer cabins than Majesty (1144 vs. 1193) so that gives Enchantment a significantly better Passenger Space Ratio (30 vs. 26). Enchantment also has a solarium and a steakhouse (Chops), neither of which are in Majesty and (IMHO) the main dining room in Enchantment is more attractive than it is on Majesty although the food itself is about the same. Finally, if you are in a suite on Enchantment, there is a Concierge Club and, while it would not make any difference to a first time cruiser, Enchantment also has a Diamond Club. Majesty has neither of those although it does cordon off part of its Viking Crown Lounge every evening to provide a happy hour event for Diamonds and Suite cruisers.

Thank you, I really appreciate the information!