St. Thomas or St. Maarten? (Scuba)

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 10:37 PM.
61 Posts
Joined Apr 2007
We're taking an Easter Caribbean cruise, and would like to dive either of these two place. (Cruise also has a shoterer stop in Nassau).

Us: I'm AOW, wife is OW. The other couple we're goimg with are OW as well.

I'm looking for two things, if I could!

1) Which island would be better?
2) A good operator? We're going to avoid the cattle boat!

Thanks in advance!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Salem, Oregon
8,469 Posts
Joined Jun 2004
Without a doubt I'd pick St. Thomas over St. Maarten for scuba diving.

I liked my trip with They pickup at the cruise dock and it isn't a cattle boat operation. There are a couple other dive OP's to consider. Chris Sawyer dive center and Blue island divers, but I haven't used either so I can't make a personal recommendation.

My St. Thomas Underwater photogallery
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Diving in Fiji was just FANTASTIC.
Littleton, Colorado, USA
117 Posts
Joined Sep 2003

I would have to say St. Thomas only because we have dived St. Maarten and did not like the experience. The dive op was less than safe (from a boat perspective), and the reefs were....well, crap. We went with Dive Safaris, which I do not recommend, and only did two dives since we were cruising, so maybe a different site and different op would yield a different opinion.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Santa Clarita Valley, CA USA
1,712 Posts
Joined Sep 2000
Bruce is right! That's easy St Thomas. We have dove there 3 times with Chris Sawyer, great operator, but you must take taxi to Red Hook to dive with them.

Love the diving here excellent coral, topography, and fauna. You won't be disappointed.

St. Marten, save your money and pick up some good bargains in town.
Great prices on cheap booze.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Norwegian Dream Mediterranean/Holy Lands 10/99
Carnival Holiday Ensenada 1/00
Renaissance R4 Tahiti 10/00
Renaissance R4 Tahiti 4/01
Windspirit Costa Rica 1/02
Windsurf Southern Caribbean 1/03
Tahitian Princess Tahiti 10/03
Dawn Princess Southern Caribbean 4/04
Tahitian Princess Polynesia/Cook Islands 10/04
Dawn Princess Western Caribbean Cruise 12/04
Sun Princess Eastern Caribbean 4/05
Sea Princess Grand Caribbean Adventure 11/05
Grand Princess Western Caribbean 2/06
Sun Princess Alaska Inside Passage 5/06
Tahitian Princess Polynesia/Marquesas 10/06
Tahitian Princess Polynesia/Cook Islands 11/06
Sea Princess Grand Caribbean Islander 2/08
Tahitian Princess South Pacific French Polynesia 10/08
Star Princess Seattle to Vancouver 09/09
Coral Princess Vancouver to Los Angeles 09/09
Sapphire Princess Seattle to Vancouver 09/10
Ocean Princess South Pacific/Tahiti Islands 1/12
Ocean Princess Sandinavia and Russia 7/12
Sapphire Princess California Coastal 10/12
Ruby Princess Venice to Rome - Greek Isles 5/13
Caribbean Princess Canada/New England 9/13
Diamond Princess Southeast Asia and Japan 4/14

Golden Princess West Coast Getaway 11/14
Dawn Princess Australia - New Zealand 3/17
Pacific Princess London - Rome 9/17
345 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
St. Thomas .......

We used Blue Island Divers, they were great. They picked us up right by our ship, and we had them all to ourselves - 3 of us plus their captain and a DM. Very nice dives.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Apr 2014 Ruby Princess: Eastern Caribbean
Nov 2013 Norwegian Dawn: Nowhere
May 2012 Carnival Sensation: Bahamas
Nov 2010 RCCL Navigator of the Seas: Western Caribbean
Oct 2008 Norwegian Star: Mexican Riviera
Aug 2007 Caribbean Princess: Eastern again! (thanks Hurricane Dean)
Jun 2005 Caribbean Princess: Eastern Caribbean
Jun 2004 RCCL Sovereign of the Seas: Bahamas
SW Ontario, Canada
8,682 Posts
Joined Apr 2006
Here is another vote for St. Thomas. Last three cruises dove here with Underwater Safari at Buck Is. which is close to Havensight cruise pier. It is only about a 20 minutes boat ride away and is the only good dive site close off of the south coast. Dive operator team were fairly good and the site offers a nice reef and a freighter wreck at same location so boat doesn't move between two dives. You go south off boat for reef and north for wreck.
Have dove St. Maarten with Dive Safari and was not as impressed.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Festival Bolero, Dec.98, E Carib* Blackbeard Pirate Lady, Jan.99, Bahamas* Sun Carousel (Nordic Prince), Feb.99, S Carib* Sun Sunbird (Song of America), Sept.99, W Med* Sun Sundream (Song of Norway), Jan.00, PC* Sea Princess, June 00, Alaska* Sun Sundream (Song of Norway), Feb.01, W Carib* Empress of the Seas, July 02, Bermuda* Grand Princess, Feb.02, W.Carib* Star Princess, Feb.03, Mexico* Enchantment OTS, March 03, E. Carib* Sun Sunbird (Song of America), June 03, W Med* Sun Sunbird (Song of America), Jan.04, S.Carib* Voyager OTS, June04, CdnMaritimes* Sun Sunbird (Song of America), Aug.04, W. Med* Maasdam, Mar.05, S.Carib* Costa Mediterranea, Apr.06, E. Carib* Regal Pr, Oct.06, PC* SerenadeOTS, Feb.07.S. Carib* Adventure OTS, Mar.07, S. Carib* Radiance OTS, Sept.07,Alaska* Legend OTS, Nov.07, E. Med* Radiance OTS, May 08, Hawaii* X Century, Dec.08, TA* Radiance OTS, Apr.09, SA to USA* X Mercury, Nov.09, E. Carib* Radiance OTS, Feb.10, Mexico, Grand Pr, Apr.10, TA* X Summit, Nov.10 B2B S. Carib* Golden Pr, Feb.11, Hawaii* X Constellation, Mar.11, S. Carib* Emerald Pr, Nov.11, S Carib* X Silhouette, Jan.12, E. Carib* X Century, Mar.12, Hawaii* Caribbean Pr, Apr.12,TA* Caribbean Pr, May 12, Br. Isles* X Eclipse, Dec.12, S. Carib* Voyager OTS, Feb.13, Oz/NZ* X Century, Nov.13, Hawaii* Ruby Pr, Feb.14, W. Carib* X Century,Feb.13, E. Carib* Serenade OTS, Apr.14, TA* Serenade OTS, Nov.14, TA* Navigator OTS, Jan.15, B2B2B W. Carib* Radiance OTS, Feb.15, Top End Oz* Freedom OTS, Oct.15,B2B E&W Carib* Anthem OTS, Jan.16, S Carib* Anthem OTS, Mar.16, W Carib* Brilliance OTS, Oct.16, TA* Anthem OTS, Jan.17, S Carib* Vision OTS, Oct-Nov17, NYC to HOU*