Trying to decide which Island to go to

[pma29223]

We're going to the Bahamas this year. I'm trying to decide what Island to go to. Which Island would you choose? Bimini, Half Moon Cay, or Coco Cay? 

[mz-s]

Half Moon Cay 100%

Not much going on in Bimini frankly...I think once Nassau is done with their construction, no Carnival ship will ever stop in Bimini again.

Carnival ships don't call at Coco Cay (you asked in a Carnival forum after all!)

[luv2kroooz]

Agree with above. Half Moon.

[Sailin_Pirate]

Pretty much depends on what you're looking for. I enjoyed Bimini a lot more than HMC and my wife seemed to enjoy HMC more.

 

HMC is beautiful , but it's a beach day. We snorkeled for hours and saw nothing. We also did the kayak excursion. In Bimini we snorkeled at a ship wreck and met some locals and shopped.