Out of these two, which is the better cruise?

[YorkieMommyKandis]

I am trying to decide between these two cruises for our second cruise (our first cruise was a 4 day Freeport, Nassau cruise).

 

LIBERTY

Eastern Caribbean: Miami, FL ; Half Moon Cay, Bahamas ; St. Thomas, USVI ; San Juan, Puerto Rico ; Grand Turk ; Miami, FL

 

OR

GLORY

Eastern Caribbean: Port Canaveral (Orlando), FL ; Nassau, Bahamas ; St. Thomas, USVI ; St. Maarten, NA ; Port Canaveral (Orlando), FL

[kimcruiser]

I voted Liberty because of the itinerary only, since I have not sailed on either of these ships I cannot say anything regarding that area. In saying that though you do have to weigh in the fact that you will be busier on the 4 stop cruise. One thing I am sure of is you will have a great time in anything you do cause youre on a cruise!:D

[neverpar]

I voted Liberty because of the itinerary only, since I have not sailed on either of these ships I cannot say anything regarding that area. In saying that though you do have to weigh in the fact that you will be busier on the 4 stop cruise. One thing I am sure of is you will have a great time in anything you do cause youre on a cruise!:D

 

Ditto.....I like the itinerary of the Liberty.....it sounds like a great cruise.

[suitegirl]

I have not been on either ship... but any chance to go to Half Moon Cay I would have to jump on that one! so I say Liberty!

[queeni]

I've been on Glory and we really enjoyed her, but I don't care for Nassau and Half Moon Cay looks great. I would go with Liberty. I am sailing that same itinerary on Freedom and can't wait!

[YorkieMommyKandis]

Thanks! I will definitely look into the Liberty cruise a bit more then. My sister has been telling me how nice Half Moon Cay is. I also like this cruise a little better since we celebrate our one year wedding anniversary on September 22 and this is the one where we would actually be on the cruise on our anniversary. Maybe my hubby won't turn himself into a cruise ship celebrity this time by joining in on the first night's show like he did last time. LOL. By the second day of the cruise, everyone was coming up to us to meet the "movie star". Fun fun fun...I can't wait!!!

[CarribbeanTina271]

I too would have to go with Liberty, those ports are great!! HMC is paradise!!!

 

Tina

[tektron]

I voted "Liberty" since I just got off the Triumph today that had an identical itinerary -- HMC, St. Thomas, San Juan, Grand Turk; and had a great time at all 4 ports. I'm writing up a picture review I'll post in a day or two.

[ahoys]

If you like the beach, definitely go for the Liberty. The itinerary is much better.

[vacruizer]

Thanks! I will definitely look into the Liberty cruise a bit more then. My sister has been telling me how nice Half Moon Cay is. I also like this cruise a little better since we celebrate our one year wedding anniversary on September 22 and this is the one where we would actually be on the cruise on our anniversary. Maybe my hubby won't turn himself into a cruise ship celebrity this time by joining in on the first night's show like he did last time. LOL. By the second day of the cruise, everyone was coming up to us to meet the "movie star". Fun fun fun...I can't wait!!!

 

LOL - same thing happened to my husband on our last cruise! All week long everyone was stopping us and making fun of him. When the CD asked him how long he'd been married, he said "forever!" and after that he was an onboard celebrity all week. :p

 

I loved sailing the Liberty - great ship. We did Western but are doing the same itin. above on our group cruise this summer. And we haven't been married "forever" - we're actually celebrating our tenth anniverary while on this summer's cruise.:D

[SandyToes1978]

I was faced with the same decision (horrors!:eek: ) as well, and we chose Liberty for our anniv. cruise because the ports sounded awesome! Plus my SIL and BIL who will be going with us already did the Glory itinerary. Something new for everyone! Have a great trip!

[Kurbanfan]

Liberty hands down..........

[MamaParrotHead]

the last 2 cruises I've been on were 3 port days, 3 sea days. And we were tired enough for doing and seeing everything to enjoy and appreciate the sea days.

 

This next cruise I've booked is 4 port days and I'm leary of it for that reason (it happens to be the Glory Western route).

 

I haven't heard great things about Grand Turk or San Juan.

 

Nassau is OK, St. THomas and St. Martin are great.

[alwaysmomof1]

Half Moon Cay is wonderful! It is such a pretty island. I would have booked another cruise just to go there but I found an awesome deal and couldn't pass it up;)

[YorkieMommyKandis]

I voted "Liberty" since I just got off the Triumph today that had an identical itinerary -- HMC, St. Thomas, San Juan, Grand Turk; and had a great time at all 4 ports. I'm writing up a picture review I'll post in a day or two.

 

 

I would love to see this! I will be looking for it.

[onceagain]

My vote would be the Liberty. We've been to the Bahama's twice and other than going to see Atlantis, we'd be fine never going there again. It was very cold each time we were there too.