RichYak

Just for reference, on my March MSC YC cruise each butler serviced about 8-9 cabins. The level of service I received was very, very good.

Access through the fitness center is on S-class ships. You will be on Apex, an E-class ship.

Brutal. So they capitulated on the misguided "Retreat Team" concept but haven't really done much about it.

When I've seen the 22/23:1 ratio, I've assumed that this was temporary until Celebrity completed re-hiring of butlers. But you used the words "fully staffed". Are you saying that this ratio is permanent?

Google “amex cruise privileges program”

This is a great thread, highlighting the differences in YC across MSC ships. Thanks @CruisnDeb for starting it.

I would think that the algorithmic maturation of the move-up program is largely to blame.

Deluxe Porthole Veranda. Unlike Infinite Verandas, there is an outdoor space, smaller than a traditional balcony, with a large porthole.

You will keep your current beverage and wifi package.

We never even found the Carousel Lounge on Meraviglia. We always turned around when we hit the casino thinking that was aft-most. Rookie mistake.

Those who are less physically able will find the separate walk-in shower to be godsent. Thankfully not an issue for us currently. Having stayed in it once given the hype here on CC, I would no longer seek it out.

Great bathroom. The rest of the cabin… meh. Very dark. The only natural light and sightlines to the ocean are the 3 ft wide door to the balcony. IMO this cabin is overrated on CC.

Hire more crew and open Luminae on port days. MSC YC can do it, why can’t Celebrity Retreat.

I imagine someone complained and asked for a credit, to be honest.

This is true. You can go to any specialty when you board. They should be able to make all your reservations from that one spot.