Explorer - May 22 - Part 2: Our Opinions

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

#1
576 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
This is a 3 part review of our May 22 – 29 Western Caribbean cruise on Explorer of the Seas. The three parts will be: The Facts, Our Observations/Opinions, and Adventure Ocean (age groups 6-8 and 15-17).

This section is OUR OBSERVATIONS/OPINIONS:


In order to appreciate our opinions, you should know that my husband and I are in our early-30’s and traveled with children ages 6 and 15. This was the children’s 4th cruise (all RCCL: Explorer, Mariner, Navigator, Explorer) and our 13th (RCCL: Nordic Prince, Grandeur, Monarch, Explorer, Mariner, Adventure, Navigator, Enchantment, Explorer and Celebrity: Mercury, Century, Century, Galaxy). Over the past 3 years my husband and I have averaged 2-3 cruises per year on RCCL. – I specify all this especially since our opinions in some cases differ significantly from others who have posted regarding this same cruise.

The Explorer, since we last sailed on her in October 2003 definitely shows signs of wear, but nothing that infringed on our enjoyment of the cruise. And I understand that Explorer will go into dry dock in a few months, so much of this will likely be upgraded. That being said, our observations were that the carpets definitely were worn (some staircase carpets were so bad that they were being replaced while we were onboard). The furniture in our cabin (JS 9598) had obviously been partially replaced. While our 2 chairs in the sitting area were very worn and faded the sofa bed (while matching the chairs exactly in fabric patern) was bright in color and looked brand new. The deck chairs had also been partially replaced (the new ones were a dark blue instead of the light aqua color I’ve seen on most RCCL ships) – most, however, were very worn and very discolored.

I felt we were “cheated” by only having 1 parade and 1 production show. As I mentioned in “The Facts” section of my review, this was the first week that this group of Singers and Dancers were working together (the CD announced that at the end of the production show). Not only did I feel cheated by the number of production shows, but the quality of the singers and dancers was sub-par. Songs out of tune, harmonies off, and one section of the dance routine looked like they had just learned it that morning (I danced for 9 years and have done routine choreography since, so I feel comfortable making that judgment).

We enjoyed a wonderful dinner at Portofino’s, but I felt the wait staff were trying to hard…they came off as almost “snooty” but in a rude way (continuously making comments about things like how fast my husband finished a course or about how someone had cleared their plate…once or twice is cute, but comments like this were made every time they approached our table!!). Scheduling Portofino’s was also tricky. We chose to schedule on Caribbean Night (Wed, Day 4, Costa Maya) and our dining room waiter told us we had made an excellent choice. What we didn’t realize when we scheduled Portofino’s for Caribbean Night was that the Repeat Guest reception was that night and, for those of you with children, it’s also the Pirate’s Parade. In addition, it was the only night the ice show is offered twice.

There was only one headliner performance that I really enjoyed and that was Mosaic (Oh, I should admit I did not see the comedian the first night because the Adventure Ocean Family Welcome Aboard Show overlaps with the main performance in the theater for main seating dinner guests). Mosaic is a vocal group of 6 guys who performed well-known songs (mostly older music) a capella (sp??) – but they actually used their voices to create the instrumental music in addition to singing the lyrics. As I said, I really, really enjoyed it…but I’ll admit that my husband had enough after the first 20 minutes.

Carly, the cruise director, was pretty good. She seemed to be having a good time and truly enjoy what she’s doing and I appreciated that she did not have any goofy catch-phrases that she said each and every time she got up on stage. She was the first CD in a while that I didn’t feel like I could predict what would come out of her mouth next.

Unfortunately, I do not have many good things to say about the CD’s staff. Other than the Activities Director, I was very unimpressed…It was interesting, however, that this was the most international CD’s staff I’ve ever experienced (usually all residents of US, Canada, UK)…but it also resulted in at least 3 of the CD’s staff being almost impossible to understand because of their accents. And, one of the CD staff who helped with verifying winning Bingo cards actually made 2 errors during the final day’s Bingo play (read the wrong numbers off the winners’ cards). It all got resolved because the winners called him back immediately, but still not acceptable.

One of the things that bugged me, although minor, was that the Cruise Compasses and kids’ Compasses often contained information that was not relevant to Explorer. There were quite a few times that information that pertains only to Mariner and Navigator were printed (e.g., incorrect names of facilities – especially on the teen’s Compasses).

Our dining room staff was acceptable, but not great. We were shocked to learn at the end of the week that our assistant waiter (female) was on her 4th contract. She served/cleared from the wrong side on occasion, often didn’t bring condiments (dressings, sauces, etc) until we’d had our food for at least 5 minutes, took quite a while to open our wine even though it was on the table upon our arrival, etc.

Speaking of wine, we ordered the Diamond wine package. I’m sorry that I can’t recall the price, but I wanted to make you aware that if you typically order white wines the selection of white wines on the Platinum and Diamond packages were identical (according to my husband) – the only difference between these 2 packages was the selection of reds.

As for ports, we only got off the ship in Costa Maya and Cozumel. In Costa Maya, we traveled by taxi (actually, a zebra open air van) to Tapas Bar in Majahual. It was a great day at the beach. We arrived in Majahual about 11:00am (ship time) and got a table and 2 lounge chairs on the beach, right at the water. We knew to look for Tapas Bar from recommendations on the Crusie Critic port of call boards. It was everything we had hoped for. In Cozumel, we lunched at Pancho’s Backyard then played a round of mini-golf (go to the flagpole downtown then walk 2 blocks inland. It was a fun course – they give you walkie-talkies to order drinks as you go around the course and we even briefly spotted the iguana that we’d read roams the course. We had a great time and very laid back – both our choices in Costa Maya and Cozumel were perfect for an enjoyable day with our kids.

Any questions, feel free to ask!!
#2
Phoenix
3,566 Posts
Joined Dec 2001
PAGA -

Thanks for your thoughts. My hubby and I are looking forward to playing mini-golf in Cozumel. It's our favorite thing to do when we visit this port! Glad you enjoyed it too!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature




RCCL Viking Seranade 4/93
Carnival Jubilee 4/95
RCCL Majesty of the Seas 4/97
Norwegian Sun 4/00
Carnival Destiny 5/01
Carnival Destiny 4/02
Carnival Pride 3/03
Carnival Spirit 3/04
Norwegian Star 3/05
RCCL Explorer of the Seas 9/05
Carnival Spirit 5/06
RCCL Freedom of the Seas 11/06
Carnival Pride 4/07
RCCL Adventure of the Seas 10/07
Carnival Destiny 5/08
RCCL Liberty of the Seas 10/08
Carnival Pride 5/10
RCCL Allure of the Seas 11/11
Celebrity Infinity 4/13
RCCL Oasis of the Seas 11/14
RCCL Radiance of the Seas 5/15
Carnival Miracle 4/16
Regal Princess 11/16
#3
Sunny AZ
23,078 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Originally posted by PAGA
The Explorer, since we last sailed on her in October 2003 definitely shows signs of wear, but nothing that infringed on our enjoyment of the cruise. And I understand that Explorer will go into dry dock in a few months, so much of this will likely be upgraded. That being said, our observations were that the carpets definitely were worn (some staircase carpets were so bad that they were being replaced while we were onboard). The furniture in our cabin (JS 9598) had obviously been partially replaced. While our 2 chairs in the sitting area were very worn and faded the sofa bed (while matching the chairs exactly in fabric patern) was bright in color and looked brand new. The deck chairs had also been partially replaced (the new ones were a dark blue instead of the light aqua color I’ve seen on most RCCL ships) – most, however, were very worn and very discolored.
You are right that we did see some signs of wear, however I was surprised that she did not show MORE signs of wear considering that she has been in service for 5 years continuously with 3,000 passengers plus crew sailing her every week! We also noticed the carpets being replaced in some public areas while we were docked in Costa Maya - we got off the ship a little later than others. We saw this as a positive thing, that maintenance was being done on a continual basis while the majority of the passengers were off the ship, to assure a great cruise experience for everyone! Other than that, I guess I was so overwhelmed by her overall beauty and grace that I just didn't notice a few wrinkles!

As far as the service, shows, etc. go - we loved it all! Much better than anything I can expect at home!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Ginny


Brilliance of the Seas ~ September 1, 2018 ~ Trans-Atlantic Amsterdam to Tampa!


My Bucket List Cruises:
Mediterranean - Booked! 10/07/17
British Isles
Baltic
European River Cruise
Northeast/Canada Fall Colors
Alaska Cruisetour
Australia/Tahiti
Hawaii - again!


Happy Memories...
Big Red Boat 06/93 (Bahamas)~ Explorer of the Seas 06/05 (Western Caribbean) ~ Jewel of the Seas 04/06 (Eastern Caribbean) ~ Monarch of the Seas 12/06 (Baja Mexico) ~ Monarch of the Seas 04/07 (Baja Mexico) ~ Golden Princess 01/08 (Mexican Riviera) ~ Explorer of the Seas 04/08 (Eastern Caribbean) ~ Caribbean Princess 05/09 (Southern Caribbean) ~ Radiance of the Seas 09/09 (Cabo San Lucas) ~ Mariner of the Seas 05/10 (Mexican Riviera) ~ Carnival Spirit 07/10 (Alaska) ~ NCL Pride of America 05/11 (Hawaii)~ Allure of the Seas 04/13 (Eastern Caribbean) ~ Jewel of the Seas B2B 05/14 (Southern Caribbean) ~ Oasis of the Seas 05/15 (Western Caribbean) ~ Jewel of the Seas 10/15 (Panama Canal) ~ Harmony of the Seas 10/16 (Transatlantic)

Oasis of the Seas 2015 Pictorial Review
Jewel of the Seas Southern Caribbean B2B 2014 Pictorial Review

Allure of the Seas 2013 Pictorial Review!

Are you an Arizona Cruiser? Come join the fun! "Never Ending Circle of Friends"
#4
Boston, Ma
149 Posts
Joined Nov 2000
I was surprised to see that the Ice Show and the one show with the singers and dancers was the exact same as last April. I also felt cheated that we didnt have more than one production with the singers and dancers and more than one parade.

but of course i still have a wonderful time even though I was slightly disappointed by a few things.

-erika
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
4/97 - Big Red Boat
4/98 - Enchantment
4/00 - Grandeur
4/01 - Grand Princess
4/02 - Voyager
6/02 - NCL Majesty
4/03 - Grandeur
4/04 - Explorer
5/05 - Explorer again
5/06-6/06 - Enchantment B2B

...I hope you understand...
I just had to go back to the island
#5
North Texas
412 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
How can I find out when Explorer will be in dry dock? We are set to cruise in March 2006 and wondered if it was before or after our cruise.
#6
Cincinnati, Ohio
18 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
It's going to dry dock at the end of September 2005.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Married on Magen's Bay, St. Thomas, Norwegian Seaward - S. Caribbean, June 1997
RCCL Sovereign of the Seas - Bahamas, May 1999
Ocean Princess - S. Caribbean, October 2000
RCCL Radiance of the Seas - S. Caribbean, January 2002
RCCL Explorer of the Seas - W. Caribbean, September 2005
Aruba - Land Trip, August 16, 2007
RCCL Adventure of the Seas - S. Caribbean, September 28, 2008
#7
North Texas
412 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
That's great news! It will be all fresh and new for us!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
06/83 Carnival Festivale12/01 Disney Magic New Year's cruise 10/04 Carnival Celebration (Scrapbooking) 06/05 Carnival Ecstasy (Girl Scout Senior Trip)
03/06 RCI Explorer of the Seas 07/06 HAL Ryndam to Alaska 10/06 Disney Wonder DVC Member Cruise 12/06 NCL Pride of Hawaii 06/07 RCI Jewel of the Seas Baltics
#8
Palm Bay, Florida
3,113 Posts
Joined Dec 2003
Originally posted by will cruise for food
How can I find out when Explorer will be in dry dock? We are set to cruise in March 2006 and wondered if it was before or after our cruise.
Good news for us, too, as we will be going to the Eastern Caribbean...sailing March 5th. Are you cruising with us?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Explorer of the Seas - 2003; Voyager of the Seas - 2004; Adventure of the Seas - 2006; Majesty of the Seas - 2006; Enchantment of the Seas - 2007; Explorer of the Seas 2008; Majesty of the Seas - 2008; Grandeur of the Seas - 2008; Grandeur of the Seas - 2009; Freedom of the Seas - 2010; Majesty of the Seas B2B - 2010; Celebrity Century 2011; Jewel of the Seas 2011; Serenade of the Seas - 2012; Jewel of the Seas - 2012; Brilliance of the Seas - 2013; Celebrity Century B2B2B - 2014; Explorer of the Seas - 2014; Explorer of the Seas - 2015; Serenade of the Seas - 2016; Empress of the Seas - 2016
#9
North Texas
412 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
No, we will be getting on when you are getting off. Since this is your second cruise on Explorer, I guess you liked it? Have a great cruise!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
06/83 Carnival Festivale12/01 Disney Magic New Year's cruise 10/04 Carnival Celebration (Scrapbooking) 06/05 Carnival Ecstasy (Girl Scout Senior Trip)
03/06 RCI Explorer of the Seas 07/06 HAL Ryndam to Alaska 10/06 Disney Wonder DVC Member Cruise 12/06 NCL Pride of Hawaii 06/07 RCI Jewel of the Seas Baltics
#10
4,132 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
Thanks for the review.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Fascination 1/02
Royal Caribbean Freedom of the Seas 7/06--Honeymoon
Royal Caribbean Majesty of the Seas 4/08
Royal Caribbean Anthem of the Seas 7/16 10 year Anniversary cruise!