We, too, were on this sailing Dec 15-22, and as said by OP pitching and rolling were present Friday, Saturday, and part of Sunday. While this is a discomfort for some we had no issues. The food under the direction of Ali Noorul was exceptional compared to past cruises. We noted seeing him everywhere food was being served. From the Lido to the Pinnacle to the Island BBQ to Canaletto, he was everywhere tasting and testing the temperatures of the foods. Yes, the weather was spotty, and light-passing showers were present throughout the week but never downpours of rain. Was this weather-wise the best cruise we've been on? No, it was not. HAL's service aboard was also exceptional and IMO the best service at sea.