It doesn't look like you're getting many good vibes here. Maybe you need some positive news which I can report. We've only tried it once on Celebration in late 2022 but it was excellent. We had the lobster mac n cheese appetizer which was delicious, and to be honest I'm not even much of a Mac n cheese person to begin with. I would have had that dish every night of the cruise if I could have! The seafood was also very good -- I prefer scallops and crabmeat or crab cakes, but DH prefers steak and "suffered" thru the seafood restaurant like a good sport. Happily, he said the steak that night was as good or better than the steakhouse. I'm sure we ordered dessert but I don't recall which and I was likely too full to have more than a bite or two anyway. I wish Rudy's would be added on more ships. Compared to Emerils, which we tried on Celebration and from the MDR favorites menu on Horizon, it was a hands-down winner. Enjoy!