We were on the Odyssey of the Seas on an 8 day cruise the week of 2/25/23 - 3/5/23. We reserved a compact car from Jay's for $81.40 on our Wednesday in port there.. We had tried Royal first as we had used them before and were fine with their service. Royal only had jeeps left when I reached out to them and those were obviously were more expensive. We walked over to the rental lot and found the Jay's guys. Royal used the same lot for our past rentals.
We went through the paperwork particulars with the Jay's guy who was in charge. After a brief conversation, he tried to upsell us on a jeep for $125. I told him that we were fine with what we reserved. We had no reason for a jeep as we were just going to the beach. As we moved through the conversation he said that he was out of compacts and we would be getting a jeep instead for the same price. Needless to say, we thought that was a crappy way to try and do business. The jeep was an older one but, again, we only needed reliable transportation. The A/C worked great. He just tried, unsuccessfully, to try and make and extra $45 off of us for no reason.
Vehicle had about a 1/4 tank of gas in it. We were told by the big guy's #2 to bring it back with the same. We went and got gas first so we would not have to deal with it later. I did put in way too much gas, filling it to 3/4 tank and we barely moved it below that. The gas was over $7 a gallon. I should have bought half the amount of fuel that I bought. Frankly, the conversion confused me and the clerks are really no help to you. You pay before you pump. They did have full service pumps but I am not sure of the price difference.
FYI.....we only saw 2 gas stations from downtown to Arashi Beach and down and back to Baby Beach. Also, the car needed to be returned by 6:00pm Aruba time keeping in mind that their time is one hour ahead of the ship's time. We got back at 5:45pm.