I don't know if his story was true but him telling us is definitely true. We didn't ask for compensation. We reported him and had him removed form our suite. It was RC and yes we still cruise with them quite frequently as they handled the situation very well on board but I still feel that corporate dropped the ball. Francois, our concierge, was outstanding and went out of his way to make our trip wonderful despite the attendant. We took the lead from our kids and have cruised regularly since the incident in 2008.