HELP!!! Another decisions thread!!!

[Coov]

OK... my wife found out over the weekend that she has earned another week of vacation. She added to the week of our currently set up cruise on the Enchantment in October - November.... my wheels are spinning so I need some nudging one way or another... options for just me and my wife...

 

Keep our current Enchantment cruise - 4 days to CocoCay and Nassau (been) and add the 3 day back to back to the same places- $569 per person

 

Freedom OTS - Have a cruise set up for next year going to St Thomas and St Martin where I have never been and looking forward to. I could cancel that one and go this year to Labadee, Falmouth, etc - $650 per person

 

Carnival Dream - Mohagany Bay, Belize, Costa Maya, Cozumel (been) - $349 per person!!!

 

Carnival Conquest - Mohagany Bay, Belize, Cozumel (been) - $309

 

All are 7 days - been on Carnival and enjoyed very much, but the Jewel blew the smaller ships away!!! I'd kinda like to have another Carnival experience on a bigger, better ship (in comparison anyway). I am a cheap man, but with loyalties to RC. What to do??? Oh, the horror!!! :)

[ryano]

Freedom of the Seas would be my choice.

 

 

Thats a crazy low price for Carnival Dream though!

[molly361]

Freedom of the Seas would be my choice as well

[Coov]

Just talked to Carnival... Looks like Dream would be more like $439.

 

There would be $110 OBC for Carnival as well. Ouch!

[Coov]

$110 OBC EACH!!! That makes it even tougher!!!

 

*I wish you could edit instead of adding another post

[Tiggertastic]

I have to say that St Maarten and St thomas are nicer than Belize etc

 

FOS for me - but you have posted it on the Royal thread so there may not be many vote carnival on here

[Coov]

Yeah, I am a RC guy... the deals are just so cheap there, it'd take other RC cruisers to convince me. I am still leaning toward Freedom though. I would be canceling my Eastern next year to take a western this year. If I could take the Eastern this year it would be a no brainer and I would not be waisting your time right now. ;)

[kaftigr]

Although Freedom would be nicer than either Carnival ship. I would keep the Freedom booking for next year and sail either Carnival 7 day cruise this year since the pricing is very cheap.

[Coov]

The cruise on Freedom for next year would stay put if I don't decide to try Freedom this year. I was/am very much looking forward to the Eastern Caribbean with St. Martin and St. Thomas. I'd hate to lose that experience. I am anxious to try Freedom though.