South Friars vs. Cockleshell

[cloudydrms]

We have been to Carambola on South Friars numerous times, and we really do love it.  I would say that the water isn't as great as it could be, but it's still nice.  The comfy chairs and vibe of Carambola we both like.  I am getting antsy to try somewhere else though, so I'm thinking about going to Cockleshell perhaps to Spice Mill.  To those of you that have been to both:  how does the food compare (Carambola is just so-so and expensive), the seating on the beach (and will it be hard to get at Spice Mill - I can reserve at Carambola which is important when the ship doesn't get in until 10:00),  and the water i.e. steep grade getting in, clearness of water, view.

 

Thanks in advance for any and all opinions and advice!

 

Cindy

[Aplmac]

Here are a few pics I took at Cockleshell Bay

- back in Dec. 2009. They may help you decide

 

That island... capped in cloud in the far distance? NEVIS.

.

[cloudydrms]

Beautiful and it honestly looks prettier than South Friars Bay.  Is that Reggae Beach Bar?

 

Cindy

[Aplmac]

7 hours ago, cloudydrms said:

Beautiful and it honestly looks prettier than South Friars Bay. 

Is that Reggae Beach Bar?

.

I'm not sure, but it could be.

 

I think I can make out a sign saying LION ROCK BEACH BAR & Grill

Fairly sure it was run by a Rasta guy...

[paul58]

The beach bar pictured is Lion's. It is next to Spice Mill. Reggea is further down to the left. https://lionrockbeachbar.shutterfly.com/