Good article. Beachbum Berry has also attempted to straighten people out on this one (as has Martin Cate and many others). Three of the ingredients above have no business being within miles of a Mai Tai. The rums are also very weak ----- Bacardi white is the Budweiser/Coors of rums and Meyers gets it's color and flavor artificially. Merchant's Reserve is a good approximation of the flavor profile Trader Vic experimented with and most serious Mai Tai afficianados favor well aged Jamaican and Martinique Agricole rums. Come to my house for a Mai Tai and you will get a Mai Tai:
Mai Tai - Trader Vic’s 1944
· 2 oz. Aged Jamaican Rum (Appleton Estate 12)
· 2 oz. Martinique Rhum Agricole (Rhum Clement VSOP)
· 1.5 oz. Fresh Lime Juice
· 1 oz. Orange Curacao (Pierre Ferrand)
· ¾ oz. Orgeat Syrup (Liber)
· ½ oz. 2:1 Demerara Simple Syrup
Place all ingredients in a cocktail shaker with crushed ice and a couple “agitator” cubes. Shake vigorously until well mixed and chilled. Pour out, with shaker ice, into a double old fashioned glass. Add extra crushed ice to fill glass. Garnish with spent lime half and mint sprigs.