Not the answer people here want to hear but the right answer that most people abide by. How many times do people want to tip for the same service? I don't like the auto gratuity, it's to high and I reduce it at guest services. Princess keeps too much of it with admin fees and allocating what was supposed to be gratuity into employee incentives, employee parties, and such. With the quantity of people on this board that tip over and above I'm sure they're getting in excess of the auto amounts.