I believe what the question was and i have the same question on an upcoming Haven cruise is that I also believe in tipping up front and then at the end . Do I tip each butler , bartender , concierge as there are probably at least 2-3 for each one ? Even though there is 24 hour butler service Im sure my butler doesnt work the entire 24 hours every day . If I give tip to bartender , concierge , butler do they share with other Haven bartenders , butler , etc that I may encounter . Thanks in advance for any help .