Respectfully disagree 100% (curious if you speak from experience). We just spent 19 nights in 2146 on Silhouette---found this to be the most convenient cabin we've ever had. Easy access to the pool---the cabins are separated from the pool area by the elevator lobby---no noise migrates to the halls. Oceanview was 1 flight up (which we heard NO noise from). This cabin is way back, almost under the sliding doors that lead to the OVC outside dining area. This balcony is larger then most (similar to the humps).