Is the Navigator an overall better ship than Freedom?

[BoiiMcFly]

Looking at reviews on travel agencies and Navigator is rated higher. From the videos they look very similar with the Freedom being a bit larger. Navigator is also older than Freedom, so why do people seem to like it better?

Edited January 30, 2017 by BoiiMcFly

[mom says]

You'll likely get more, informed answers if you ask on the RCI board. Here's the link: http://boards.cruisecritic.com/forumdisplay.php?f=83

[cb at sea]

Freedom is merely a "stretched" version of the Voyager class.....

 

Each trip is different...even on the SAME ship! It's the passenger mix that gives a cruise it's "feel".

 

Pick the ship with the price and itinerary that suits you best...then stop reading reviews!

[Sequim88]

Everything you might want to know about Voyager class ships... Voyager-Class

 

Navigator and Mariner are 2nd generation V class and thus lean a little more like their slightly larger sisters. Comparison

[taglovestocruise]

If you scroll to the top and look at all reviews you will see that Freedom beats Navigator in almost every category. That includes cc editor reviews as well as members. happy cruising

[shelbelle99]

Looking at reviews on travel agencies and Navigator is rated higher. From the videos they look very similar with the Freedom being a bit larger. Navigator is also older than Freedom, so why do people seem to like it better?

 

I have been on both and would highly recommend Freedom. Love Captain Holmes and his crew.