Help us decide which cruise!

Our family of very inexperienced cruisers are looking to go on a 4 day reunion cruise in October. I think we've narrowed it down to two cruises, but this being the first cruise for the vast majority of us, we just don't know which. Our party will have 21 people total, ranging from 9 months to 59, with everything in between. We're not drinkers but love good food, and adventure. Right now, I think we're more excited by the destinations, but we don't really know if that's the right mind set. Thanks so much for your help!

#1- Norwegian Sky- Grand Bahamas Island, Great Stirrup Cay, Nassau

#2- Royal Caribbean, Majesty of the Seas- Nassau, Coco Cay, Key West

#2- Royal Caribbean, Majesty of the Seas- Nassau, Coco Cay, Key West

Welcome to Cruise Critic! :)

#2 Because Key West and Coco Cay are very good port stops.

Also, Royal Caribbean is a good fit for most. :)

LuLu

Welcome to Cruise Critic.

I also like Royal Caribbean's cruise -- those ports are great.

I cruised both many times. Without a doubt, go with Majesty of the Seas. The itinerary is better, and so is the cruise line.

We have sailed on both lines and like both, but RC gets the nod on this one. Ocruiser hit the nail on the head. Key West and Coco Cay are fun. Never cared for Nassua, but many people like it. The only thing that I wanted to do there was swim with the sharks at Stewart Cove. DW said that there was no way she would do it. While there we walked to the Fish Fry and had a major Pig Out. Great Food.

Another vote for RCI

Although I am a loyal NCL cruiser I have to give this one to Royal Caribbean. Key West is a great port!

Been on both. Definitely RCI.

Royal Caribbean hands down. Key West is great. Never been to Coco Key but it is on my list.

Well, I certainly wasn't expecting such agreement! Y'all make our decision much easier. Thank you!