LOL help solve a family arguement

Compare the Freedom to the Liberty? Which in your opinion is bigger or better?

I've cruised them both in the past year or so and found them to be very similar in size and layout. I thought the service was better on the liberty though. Overall enjoyed them both.

They are both Conquest Class ships so are virtually identical in size.

Personally we prefer Fantasy class, so we think smaller is better. Just throwing that out there.

Been on both and they are sister ships - so about identical in size. They differ in their 2.0 upgrades. Liberty was the 1st ship to get the make over and doesn't have the same upgrades as Freedom like the Red Frog Pub. This IMO gives the edge to Freedom for that. However, the decor on Liberty is one of the best in the Fleet - she is a beauty.

If trying to decide between the two - I would choose the one which has the better itinerary. Right now I think the Liberty is doing 4 and 5 day runs where the Freedom is doing 7 day runs. For that fact alone, I would choose the Freedom.

When are you going?

Same.

The ship list:

https://www.cruisedeckplans.com/DP/deckplans/cruiseline.php?line=Carnival

I preferred the Freedom because it has Red Frog Pub and the Liberty doesn't. We hung out in there almost nightly - great live music and dancing.

We really missed it on the Liberty.

All three of the Conquest-class ships I've been on were pretty much the same, other than their 2.0 upgrades. I'd choose by itinerary and price.

I like the freedom more than the liberty. Since the ships are pretty much identical, it comes down to the style/decor and i liked the Freedom more. A few years ago we did B2B, liberty on week 1 and Freedom on week 2, we haven't booked the liberty since...

I like the Freedom better- but I probably would not cruise on either again. I just like the bigger ships better.