Would you sail on RCI's new ship?

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

#1
New York City
551 Posts
Joined Jun 2004
I will only post this thread on boards with large ships, CCL, Princess and RCI. Would you sail on the new Genesis Of the Seas? Lets looks at some Positive and Negative points of the new MEGA ship, and please do add if u think of some, and please, its only MY opinion, And everyone can express there opinion, I think
Positives: Alot of crap to do, If you like to be busy, This is your ship that is boarding.
- Getting to try alot of firsts, We know when RCI has a new Biggest ship,something new is bound to come along as features
- Good pricing, I think so, I mean, the more heads they can stuff onboard, the lower the prices would be, I am not sure if it is, Atleast the first voyages dont count as they are maiden.

I honestly think there are alot more Negative points to this ships size
- Long ass lines, I mean come on, 6400 passengers to feed for breakfeast, lunch and dinner, Holy crap, if people have complained of cold food coming to the table, get use to it
- Getting of and on the ship. 6400 people on a line? Enough said!!!
- Tendering, Should i even say more. Wait, Perhaps they found Celebrity's Zenith a new job.
- Service, Ok so a ship with like 2200 passengers has like 900 crew members, so GOS is almost 3 times that, and RCI is not putting 2400 crew members onboard. Or are they? I dont think so, Poor Service? Its a good question!
- Ports, What ports can handle her? Miami? Ya ok, thats a start, Sure Grand Cayman, but even Zenith cant help here. Do i see long lines. Costa Maya, ya maybe. St Thomas, well she would take the space of 2 ships, and could she even get in the harbor. Puerto Rico, Can she make those turns to get in, And what about NYC, sure Red Hook would do, But I dont think Carnival and NCL are willing to share. Would Bayonne do, I dont know?
- Now looking at her from the point of view of other ships arriving at a port where she is. I think the concept of no shore excursions would take place. She has 6400 passengers doing tours. WOW! I think i will stay onboard. Shopping, Hm, Doesnt this seem like Christmas eve all over again? And this line looks like The East Bound Belt Parkway. OMG, Shoot me NOW!!! Oh and i think Deck Chair Hogs would take new meaning? Whats this, RCI is taking reservations for Chairs?? Holy Cow
Ok, and here is a HOTT topic. KIDS. Ok, dont get me wrong, I love kids, But when packs form, LOOK OUT . 1000 kids onboard will probably be the average number. Is it just me or do i actually see people jumping off as soon as they see land...., Wait, thats just me jumping Cuba Hoo
And one note that isnt really funny. God forbid something happens onboard, Fire, Sinking, anything, Imagine 6400 pax trying to get of. Arent ships crew trained to get all of in 30 mins of less? I think thats what i have heard. Doesnt the number of passengers change the time in which everyone should be off a ship in an emergency? I think there is a Maritime Law for that.

Again, This is my opinion. And I just might probably here sssooo much about my comments, But, As i said, Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
In No Order...

Caribbean Princess x2
Carnival Legend x2
Queen Mary 2
Crown Princess
Quantum Of The Seas
Carnival Imaganation
HAL Westerdam
HAL Veendam
HAL Zuiderdam
Golden Princess
Island Princess
Seabourn Pride
Carnival Splendor
#2
Lake Mary, Florida
1,046 Posts
Joined Sep 2005
That ship is just too big. Wont be sailing on it.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Previous Voyages:
-Disney Magic - 3/2001
-Disney Magic - 3/2002
-Disney Magic - 6/2004
-RCI Navigator of the Seas 5/28/05
-RCI Legend of the Seas 3/11/06
~RCI Mariner of the Seas 3/11/07
~RCI Sovereign of the Seas 10/12/07
~RCI Enchantment of the Seas 5/26/08
~Disney Magic - 10/11/08
~RCI Navigator of the Seas - 2/ ? /09
~Disney Wonder - 9/10/09
~RCI Freedom of the Seas - 5/30/10
~Disney Wonder ~ 11/24/10
~Disney Dream ~ 3/31/11
~RCI Freedom of the Seas - 5/01/11
~RCI Freedom of the Seas - 9/30/12
~RCI Enchantment of Seas 9/13/13
~RCI Freedom of the Seas - 9/14/14
~RCI Oasis of the Seas - 5/23/15

Upcoming:
RCI Majesty of the Seas - 4/10/2017
RCI Oasis of the Seas - 10/08/2017
#3
Michigan,USA
621 Posts
Joined Sep 2002
I totally agree that the negatives outweigh the positives, for a ship of that size.

I prefer the initimacy of the Serenade Of The Seas.

6,400 people! I envision a nightmare, with every aspect of cruising.

What is going to be the ratio of passengers to crew? I can't help but wonder how the great RCCL quality of service can be maintained, on that monster?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Celebrity Constellation
RCCL Serenade of the Seas(my sentimental favorite)
Carnival Destiny
RCCL Adventure of the Seas
Serenade of the Seas(two cruises)
#4
Atascocita, Texas
4,809 Posts
Joined May 2003
Maybe Maybe Not..

Yes,there will be more people...Ok...tons more people.But that also means more space,more rooms more venues.More Dining options.Hopefully bigger Theatres..So it might not matter..

What causes me the most concern is the number of folks unloading on an Island at one time..Not to mention how long it could take to tender..But good grief...Its already Chaos with 3-4 ships (and many times more) at 2800-3600 per...Can you imagine that plus 3 ships with almost 7000 per ship
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
#5
Houston TX
3,536 Posts
Joined Aug 2002
not if I can help it. I went on Voyager and didnt like it because it was too big. Ill stick to the smaller ships.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Voyager 10/04
Rhapsody 10/02 03/02 1/02 11/01 10/05 05/06 5/07
Elation 10/99
Grandeur 09/97
Princess 03/08

Rhapsody of the Seas May 6 -13 cruise compasses
Dawn Princess -March 2, 2008 - Mexican Riviera - Escape with me!!
#7
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
103 Posts
Joined Dec 2005
I'd sail on it.

As far as tendering and/or getting on and off in port goes, I would assume that they don't build a ship that holds twice the passengers without doubling the on-off capacity. That means twice the number of gangplanks... spread out along the length of the ship. And twice the number of tenders. And since the thing takes up the space of two ships in port... well there won't be any more people in each port then will there? There will be one less ship but the same number of people swarming the port area.

Keep in mind that I've never sailed on a small ship before... just Radiance class and Voyager class. Neither felt too big to me.

Like all things I guess it just depends on your personal taste.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Mariner of the Seas (back to back cruises), March 2006
Brilliance of the Seas, March 2004
Adventure of the Seas, September 2002
#8
Fredericksburg, va. USA
82,096 Posts
Joined May 2001
I think I'd wait and see how it goes. It does seem awfully big and impersonal. I think I'd be a little afraid, too. Like you said, if there was an emergency--it's like evacuating a small town. At this point--no thanks!
#9
Southern California
36,435 Posts
Joined Oct 2005
I don't pick a cruise just for the ship. If the ship offered an itinerary I liked, I would sail on it. If not, then no.
#11
Wood Dale, IL
534 Posts
Joined Nov 2002
Originally posted by Cuizer2
I don't pick a cruise just for the ship. If the ship offered an itinerary I liked, I would sail on it. If not, then no.
I'm with you on that one.

Which is why I won't be going on the Freedom anytime soon.

We wish all of the itinerary's we liked were on Voyager class ships(our favorite) but unfortunately thats not the case.
#12
Highland, IN
2,386 Posts
Joined Oct 2005
Don't think you will find us on this one. Embarkation/debarkation would be a nightmare. People moving is just not of RCI's strong points. Don't get me wrong - I love Royal Caribbean, and after 7 cruises in 3 1/2 years we know patients is a virtue. I just can not see this working well.
Limited ports due to her size and can you imagine the departure ports? 6,000 people trying to find a hotel room the night before their cruise? Ooh boy, I think I will pass. Sorry RCI.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Terri
#13
1,216 Posts
Joined Oct 2000
I really have no desire to sail on the Voyager class.. I'll only be on the Freedom for the pre-inaugural and the same with Genesis-- after that-- NO THANKS!! I prefer the Vision and Radiance class.
#14
Victoria, MN
397 Posts
Joined Dec 2002
Sign me up, I'd love to sail her. All the negatives posted are based on trying to stuff more passengers into a ship design like the current ships. I think when this ship launches we will see some new and interesting facilities that will be designed for this many people. like multiple tenders, mulitple dinning rooms and kitchens. What if the 3 1000 person dinning rooms each with there own kitchen?

so I can't wait to step foot on her. But again I love to go christmas shopping on xmas eve and the day after thanksgiving!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Charlie and Deb

"Changes in latitudes, changes in attitudes nothing remains quite the same. With all of our running and all of our cunning, If we couldn't laugh, we would all go insane." -- Jimmy Buffett

Next Up:


Carnival Jubliee - to long ago to remember
Sovereign of the Seas - early 90's sometime
Disney Magic - Maiden Voyage - East Caribbean
Navigator of the Seas - 1/2003 - East Caribbean Got engaged on this one!
Caribbean Princess 4/23/2005 - East Caribbean
Rhapsody of the Seas 1/22/2006 - West Caribbean
Voyager of the Seas 1/27/2007 - East Caribbean
Freedom of the Seas 3/2008 - West Caribbean
Rhapsody of the Seas 11/2009 - Australia
Vision of the Seas 1/25/2011 - East Caribbean

#15
New Jersey
702 Posts
Joined Mar 2002
I agree with the OP about the reasons for not sailing a ship of this magnitude. I cannot conceive of them making the amenities proportionatly larger with the increase in passengers and staff. The top deck surface area is not going to double, which means the pools and outdoor things are going to suffer an enormous increase in demand. I think theidea of reserving deck chairs is not all that far off. Sea days will be a like rush hour in New York. I think RCCL lost sight of the fact that sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.
Jerry
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Eclipse 1/17
Infinity 3/16
Silhouette 1/16
Silhouette 10/15
Eclipse 1/15
Breakaway 4/14
Eclipse 1/14
A bunch of others
#16
214 Posts
Joined Jan 2006
My friends and I will be on the Genesis class ship as soon as they begin accepting reservations. But they need to let us reserve now as it will take three years to pay for a balcony on that behemoth for sure!

Contrary to most posts I've read here and at other boards, I prefer larger ships. We were on the Jewel in December and I was just so disappointed about the lack of Voyager class space, activities, and I really missed the Promenade. I kept thinking: we need to get ice show tickets then I remembered: no ice skating rink. Bummer! The Jewel was lovely, but it did not compare IMHO to the Voyager class ships I've sailed (Mariner, Adventure). We are booked on the Freedom of the Seas this year--Aug. 6. There are just so many more options on RCI's larger ships, and I'm sure that crowding issues at tendering, meal times, etc., will be well-thought out and at worst a minor inconvenience just as they are on the Voyager lines now. I'm sure there were similar fears about Voyager-class ships years before they debuted yet they remain popular and will probably become industry standard in years to come.

By the time Genesis sails, I should have about RCI 10 sailings under my belt. Maybe we'll be able to book the inaugural!!
#17
214 Posts
Joined Jan 2006
... to the RCI powers that be if they are lurking at this board. Re future Genesis features: (1) a true movie theater with popcorn, not some glorified little conference room with a screen; (2) pool tables?????; and (3) figure out a way to pipe in more than one or two NFL football games during football season/playoffs. I am a Redskins fan. Could you mix in some NFC games???? The world does not revolve around Cleveland and Green Bay!! That will be all for now. There will be more suggestions after our August Freedom cruise!!
#20
214 Posts
Joined Jan 2006
You're in the majority. I just like to have as many options as possible on board and loads of people to sit, have a drink, and gawk at as they come and go. And I just want to see what RCI will come up with to differentiate the Genesis line from Voyager.