Brief Trip Report: SD1

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

SeaDream Yacht Club

Read SeaDream Yacht Club Cruise Reviews written by cruisers just like you.

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 02:32 PM.
#1
Oregon Coast
10 Posts
Joined Mar 2010
Hey, everyone!
I found this site when I was researching SD and found some great tips and insight here. I have never posted here but since I enjoyed reading others trip reports I thought I would share my experience on my first SD cruise.

We left St Thomas on 03-29 and sailed for 9 days on SD1. I can honestly say that this was the most fun I have ever had on a vacation. Even though I had a good idea of what to expect, the level of service and extraordinary ability of the staff to to make you feel welcome and comfortable was mind blowing.
I know the staff has extensive training in recognition but how they were able to call me by name within hours of embarking is a mystery to me! Also, there can be a fine line between excellent service and 'stuffiness', and these guys are masters. They seemed to know when and with whom they could be more playful as opposed to being in '5 star mode'. I am amazed that one company could find so many highly skilled and yet warm and friendly servers. They truly made this cruise a unique and wonderful experience. Without exception.
The cuisine was jaw dropping. My companion and I are both 'foodies' and know our way around fine dining, but I have never taken a picture of my plate until now...and I think I took 20 pics of the meals! Gorgeously presented, and layers of flavors and textures that will curl your toes, every time! Wow. Just, wow. I asked the chef if we could tour the galley and he agreed. He took a group of us (champagne and caviar in hand) through the kitchen and gave us an incredibly interesting look at the workings of the SD galley--including things I had never thought of, such as how the dishware has to be secured in cages so as not to fly about during swells, and how the garbage is a very big deal since they can't unload waste at our ports of call. Really interesting! I also loved that they provided copies of the menus (signed by the chef and sommelier) for anyone who was interested at the end of the trip.
Capt. Valter Berg is great. He pops up periodically to check on your dinner or to say hello poolside. He also moved the ship to open water one evening because there were 'too many bugs' in the harbor. Seriously? Hard to beat that kind of service!
Richard was our tour director and is also awesome. Along with his wife he made sure everyone had a great time on the excursions. He played a great practical joke on us for April Fools. He came on the intercom during breakfast and announced that a school of flying fish had hit the ship over night and some of them had landed in the pool...hurry if you wanted to see them as the staff was draining the pool! Well, all hell broke loose as we all grabbed our cameras and stampeded to the pool deck only to see one very confused looking passenger sitting by the pool looking up at us. That was hysterical. What a bunch of dufus's!
One note, however--I asked the concierge to remind the ladies that it often rains in the rainforest! (speaking of dufus's) Therefore, do not wear a thin, white t-shirt for the two hour hike through the jungle? I know, that was pretty dumb of me.
The ports of call were interesting and fun. We often found beaches on our own instead of taking an excursion, although with the exception of the rainforest fiasco all of the excursions were a blast. Especially Montserrat--the devastion caused by the volcano is truly chilling; that was a really unique experience.
That said, I think the most fun I had on ship was with the water toys. The jet ski was a blast. The banana boat was so fun I was hoarse for a few days from screaming my head off. And the kayak and water trampoline and free swims...oh, my! Sigh...and their attention to safety was appreciated. We wore helmets for the banana boat and there was always a watchful crewmember in the zodiac when passengers were in the water.

I asked if we could tour the bridge and it was arranged promptly...while sailing, to boot! That was pretty interesting. While the guys were checking out the equipment I noticed the video monitor trained on the pool...hmm. I asked the chief officer if he was keeping up with the latest trends in bikini's? He immediately changed the view back to the side of the ship and said "No this is for docking and lowering the tender and so forth".
Riiiight. (LOL--after 4 months at sea who could blame them for that? I would have it trained on the pool, too!)

When researching this ship I thought the day beds would be a dream come true, especially since I love to sleep with fresh air and under the stars. Not so good. That mattress is rock hard. The hair blowing on my face was annoying and the 2 am sudden downpour put a (ahem) damper on things. I limped back to my room in the middle of the night and resigned myself to being rocked to sleep by the gentle swells in my nice, dry, Belgian linen. A few of us mentioned this to the Capt. and we suggested a yoga mat or something would be helpful for the overnighters. We'll see!
Bartenders--Alex is a rockstar. He put on a stellar bottle tossing show for us poolside during "Caribbean Night'. All of the bartenders were great. I learned to ask them to 'fix me something fun' and had some great new cocktails I would never have discovered on my own.
Our Sommelier, Michael, was my personal favorite, and not just because he is a fellow Canadian. He spent a lot of time with us helping to discern our taste and answering our questions. One afternoon he even caught up with me to preview the dinner menu so he could offer the perfect wines for our dinner with the Captain. When I told him I had a friend who would love to bend his ear about his job he did not hesitate to offer his e-mail address so he could answer her questions regarding this career. What a sweetheart!
The other passengers really made this trip, as well. It seemed everyone was happy and relaxed and having a great time. People seemed to settle in to their own comfort zone, whether dining in intimate parties of two or four or gathering in a large table of new friends every night. The crew seemed very tuned to everyone's preferences and asked how we preferred to be seated every night. I am glad that we chose a 9 day cruise. It really took a few days to meet everyone and develop friends and 'acclimate' to the ship...I remember thinking on day 5 that I would be really upset if we had to leave now that we had just found all these great people! I definately recommend the 9 days if you can swing it.
In the end, I told SD in my comment card that I have been ruined for any other cruise line. Why would anyone choose a ship where you have to fight for a chair by the pool and where you are told when and with whom you are going to dine? Where you are herded like sheep on and off the ship? Where the officers are invisible and you have to take a taxi from one end of the ship to the other? Yuck! Never again!
I have never in my life felt so pampered and yet without snobbery. It was fantastic. From the little table with white linen and drinks/fruit that greeted us on the tender dock to the quaint gifts left on our bed every night, the details made me feel like a princess.
It was very hard to come home and pick up dog turds.
Thanks for listening. It's an honour and great pleasure to be a new member of the SeaDream Yachter's Club!
Kelly
#2
Germany
1,073 Posts
Joined Oct 2008
Thanks for a fine review! Glad you had fun. Your comments are making me look forward to our cruise next week! Too bad it's only 5 days!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature













Our first cruise- Vision of the Seas- June 4, 2009 Baltics
#5
17,660 Posts
Joined Mar 2005
Great review and welcome to the boards. You are right, it is hard to do the big ships after SD.

Oh well we only have 41 days until we board in Athens.
#6
Along the Hudson River in NY
3,403 Posts
Joined Jun 2003
Welcome to the world of posting and SD Kelly

Thanks for sharing your experience on SD1 with us! It is always wonderful to read trip reports, especially from first timers! Helps with the SD withdraw

I agree Ctbjr ... Nov. 8 can't get here soon enough!!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

#7
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
bytemewalker:
Sounds like you had the basic, normal, run of the mill SeaDream trip. You are now officially ruined for anything less. You might try something else from time to time, but you will run back as fast as possible.
Jim.
#8
Along the Hudson River in NY
3,403 Posts
Joined Jun 2003
Originally posted by Jim Avery
bytemewalker:
Sounds like you had the basic, normal, run of the mill SeaDream trip. You are now officially ruined for anything less. You might try something else from time to time, but you will run back as fast as possible.
Jim.
Does that mean you will be coming back to SD after your trip on Seabourn Yes, I saw you posting over there
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

#9
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Originally posted by DisneyJen
Does that mean you will be coming back to SD after your trip on Seabourn Yes, I saw you posting over there
Oops! Busted! Ganttc made us do it, even Lazy Seadreamer. Yes, of course we will be back. Have one picked out, just waiting for James C. to call and make me an offer I can't refuse. Gantt is supposed to be working on a CC cruise. Just could not pass up the rate on this one.
J.
#10
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Originally posted by DisneyJen
Does that mean you will be coming back to SD after your trip on Seabourn Yes, I saw you posting over there
Besides, you are not supposed to be lurking over there. You will get SeaDream demerits.
#11
Along the Hudson River in NY
3,403 Posts
Joined Jun 2003
Originally posted by Jim Avery
Oops! Busted! Ganttc made us do it, even Lazy Seadreamer. Yes, of course we will be back. Have one picked out, just waiting for James C. to call and make me an offer I can't refuse. Gantt is supposed to be working on a CC cruise. Just could not pass up the rate on this one.
J.
There are some very good rates on SB right now ... I have been tempted but DJ's DH will NOT step foot on SB again ... too formal and big for him when he is in "chill" mode

I think it will be a good experience for you and Lois

Originally posted by Jim Avery
Besides, you are not supposed to be lurking over there. You will get SeaDream demerits.
Not lurking ... spying ... so that means I get SeaDream kudos/points/rewards

Of course we ALL will be expecting a FULL compare and contrast trip report!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

#13
Oregon Coast
10 Posts
Joined Mar 2010
Originally posted by Ragnar Danneskjold
Maybe if Mrs. Danneskjold wears a soaking wet thin t-shirt back from a shore excursion the crew will give us extra-special service too
Ragnar--
Riiight...perhaps 20 yrs ago I could've given someone a thrill--as it was it was more like a horror show!! (speaking as a 48 yr old)

Meanwhile, Bon Voyage to everyone booked for the coming cruises. Thanks for your comments and have a GREAT time!
Kelly
#14
Atlanta
168 Posts
Joined Sep 2009
Disney Jen...Funny that you busted Mr. Jim. I love that. And he can blame me all he wants, BUT...there was no arm twisting. The deals are there for sure. If you'll just join us we'll have a swell time. None of us are formal! It is a great itinerary and super-duper pricing. I'm mega excited about SD1 in 44 days! YEAH! And yes, we'll be back again to SD "empty my bank account again" - hopefully in January with Jim and Lazy...IF we get along on the SB trip. That's very iffy.
#15
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Originally posted by ganttc
Disney Jen...Funny that you busted Mr. Jim. I love that. And he can blame me all he wants, BUT...there was no arm twisting. The deals are there for sure. If you'll just join us we'll have a swell time. None of us are formal! It is a great itinerary and super-duper pricing. I'm mega excited about SD1 in 44 days! YEAH! And yes, we'll be back again to SD "empty my bank account again" - hopefully in January with Jim and Lazy...IF we get along on the SB trip. That's very iffy.
I do blame you. You and your formal speedos. Besides, we are not "iffy", you have already sailed with us "stone statues by the pool".
#16
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Hey Gantt:
I'm impressed, you even put us on your countdown clock. I can't seem to make them work through Firefox/Mac. Thanks for the mention.
J & L.
#17
Along the Hudson River in NY
3,403 Posts
Joined Jun 2003
Originally posted by ganttc
Disney Jen...Funny that you busted Mr. Jim. I love that. And he can blame me all he wants, BUT...there was no arm twisting. The deals are there for sure. If you'll just join us we'll have a swell time. None of us are formal! It is a great itinerary and super-duper pricing. I'm mega excited about SD1 in 44 days! YEAH! And yes, we'll be back again to SD "empty my bank account again" - hopefully in January with Jim and Lazy...IF we get along on the SB trip. That's very iffy.
Sounds like a great itinerary but the timing won't work for us ... too close to our Fall Crossing on SD2.

Would love to join you but I don't see it in the cards for us this round ...
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

#18
549 Posts
Joined Nov 2006
Originally posted by Jim Avery
Hey Gantt:
I'm impressed, you even put us on your countdown clock. I can't seem to make them work through Firefox/Mac. Thanks for the mention.
J & L.
Yeah - he put you & Lois, but not me & Doug. Guess I know where I stand...
#19
Valley of the Sun, Arizona
7,247 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Originally posted by Cammiem
Yeah - he put you & Lois, but not me & Doug. Guess I know where I stand...
I would really make him pay for that. Maybe when you guys go to dinner. Make him pay and order the steak and the lobster.