We are booked for our 27th cruise this Sept. We’ve been cruising since the late 80’s, early 90’s. Started with Cunard, then Celebrity, RCCL, NCL and Carnival. In Feb. 2020, we decided to try RCCL again on Grandeur out of Baltimore. We were on RCCL’s Empress of the Seas years ago.
To be honest, cruising today is not like it was when we took our earlier cruises. For us, the Grandeur was very nice, but not much different from our Carnival Pride cruise in Dec. 2019. I liked the food on Carnival a little better, I wasn’t crazy about the buffet seating/layout on RCCL, and the Grandeur was pretty quiet after 10P.M., except in the casino. These were minor differences for us. Loved our junior suite on Grandeur.
Would we book RCCL again, absolutely. A cruise today is just a mode of transportation from one location to another, geared specifically to families at least on NCL, RCCL, Carnival. Give RCCL a try; I think you’ll find it pretty much the same as others you noted.
We like the older, smaller ships, but next year, I’ll leave DH at home, and try a girl’s cruise on Anthem.