@mac_tlc, seems like we have the same viewpoint and are also trying to figure out what works best for us.
Have Retreat on Ascent in Feb, then O Vista ( PH), 1200 is the smallest we would do at this point, in July and we’ve even booked NCL in 2025.( may change to X, once I see Iceland/ Norway routes and ships).
We do land trips in between and at this point no brand loyalty.
Hope you’ll write a review of your O cruises, would love to hear your opinion. Thanks.