The category you book and pay for is controlling. In this case it would be VH. So, if there is a price decrease for VH you would be eligible. However, it is very hard to get the phone reps to understand this. Usually I have to ask for a pricing specialist who has more experience and is familiar with this.
I was just looking at a travel agent website and it would only show me cabins available for 2 on the Koningsdam in the Caribbean March 2026. Anything for 3 or 4 was not shown. Then I went to the HAL website and it was the same thing. They must be serious about this.
The new Caribbean cruises have been posted for Fall 2025 and Spring 2026. Looks like the same old itineraries. New is that the Koningsdam will sail in the Caribbean out of Fort Lauderdale and the Zuiderdam will sail out of Miami.
I think in this case the person was asking about buying a better cabin but did not have an official offer for an upsell. She wanted to upgrade to the lowest available category and then get upgraded with CO.
Why not call and ask HAL your question? Then you can decide what to do. Ask to be connected with a pricing specialist. They seem to be more knowledgeable than the people who answer the phone.
I don't drink a lot but the reason I get the drink package is for the convenience of not having a lot of extra charges. It defeats the purpose to have extra charges to get the drinks I want like a basic pina colada. Also, many of the glasses of wine are over the limit. Maybe they are trying to get everyone to upgrade to the elite package.
So what is the purpose of a drink package if everything has an extra charge? Will this hurt the sale of drink packages? I would rather have them limit the number of drinks per day than limit the price.
I was surprised at how much I liked the Rotterdam since my previous favorites were the smaller R class ships. I actually found the Eurodam and Nieuw Amsterdam to be more crowded.
Since the beds are located near the balcony, I would assume that the sofa with the pullout bed would be near the bathroom in all the vista cabins. (Unless there is an exception for a handicapped cabin.) Of course, make sure that the cabin indicates room for 3 people so the sofa will include the pullout bed.